“Confirmed Judges, Confirmed Fears” is a blog series documenting the harmful impact of President Trump’s judges on Americans’ rights and liberties. It includes judges nominated in both his first and second terms.
What’s at stake in this case?
An immigrant from Colombia was ordered to be deported despite claims that the Colombian government could or would not protect him from paramilitary groups upon his return.
What happened in this case?
The federal Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) affirmed an Immigration Judge(IJ) decision and ordered the deportation of Julian Alberto Marino Clavijo, an immigrant from Colombia. He asked for a stay of the deportation until his case was fully reviewed in court, but Trump judges Ryan Nelson and Daniel Collins refused and denied the motion for a stay, although Clinton judge Richard Paez dissented, in the November ruling in Clavijo v Blanche. In a brief order, the majority vacated a temporary administrative stay and stated that Clavijo had not justified a longer stay.
Why did Judge Paez dissent?
Judge Paez explained that Clavijo had made a “strong showing” that the BIA had applied the wrong standard of review to the IJ decision and had “overlooked record evidence” that the Colombian government would be “unable or unwilling” to protect him from paramilitary groups when he was returned there. Paez would have kept the stay in place pending full review to prevent “permanent and irreversible harm.”
Why is this decision harmful?
The ruling by Trump judges Collins and Nelson obviously harms Julian Alberto Marin Clavijo, who faces immediate deportation and likely injury from paramilitary groups. It also sets a bad precedent concerning stays of deportation, particularly in the Ninth Circuit, which includes California, Arizona, Alaska, Hawaii, Idaho, Montana, Nevada, Oregon, and Washington. The decision also illustrates the importance of our federal courts to health, welfare and justice and the significance of having fair-minded judges on the federal bench.